14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (2024)

Anna Kovel

·3 min read

Bring something new to the Thanksgiving table by making one of these alternatives to cranberry sauce.

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (1)

No cranberries, no problem! For those looking for an alternative to cranberry sauce to serve with turkey, there are plenty of condiments to make instead. Consider a chutney with fresh and dried fruit, a tangy citrus marmalade, and even bacon-onion "jam." The recipes we've gathered are sweet and tart or savory and aromatic, they include the spices, nuts, and deep flavors we associate with autumn and winter, so you won't miss the cranberries one bit.

And if there will be one person at the table who always has to have the cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving, then fine—it's easy to make a batch for them too. Or if you don't mind cranberries but aren't a fan of the usual sauce, we've included a couple of decidedly different cranberry condiments to try.

Related: 24 Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Recipes That'll Save You Time on the Big Day

Gingered Golden Fruit Chutney

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (2)

Keeping it seasonal with apples and adding ginger and spice, this chutney checks all the holiday table boxes.

View Recipe

Tangerine and Lemon Marmalade

A citrus marmalade can be eaten with sweet or savory food. The slices of fruit of tart fruit have just enough bitterness in their peel to balance the sweetness.

View Recipe

Quince Butter

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (4)

Fruit butter is an old-fashioned term for a puree of fruit that cooks for so long it becomes spreadable. It's magical, especially when made with quince, a fall fruit with an unparalleled fragrance.

View Recipe

Plum Ginger Relish

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (5)

Pretty, sunset hues and a gingery zing makes this relish a perfect partner for turkey and a star of the Thanksgiving table.

View Recipe

Quince Jelly With Star Anise

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (6)

The longer quince is cooked, the rosier it becomes in color. Here it’s made into a syrup which is cooked for so long that the fruit’s natural pectin, contained in skin and seeds, helps it to set.

View Recipe

Warm Plum Sauce

This is a luscious sauce of softened plums simply cooked with balsamic vinegar and garlic. You can use any type of ripe plums but Italian prune plums are the best for this easy sauce.

View Recipe

Quick Pear Chutney

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (8)

A recipe like this will fall into your annual rotation: it’s pretty and bright, with barely-cooked pears and warm spices. Honey adds a light sweetness, and walnuts add crunch.

View Recipe

Bacon Jam

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (9)

"Bacon in jam?" you might ask. And we say adding sweet, slowly cooked onions with savory bacon bits to your turkey plate would be a Good Thing.

View Recipe

Pomegranate Relish

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (10)

Raw and bright, fresh pomegranate tossed with lemon and herbs is a most worthy partner to turkey and a superb alternative to a no-cook, chopped cranberry and orange relish.

View Recipe

Date Chutney

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (11)

If you like the rich taste of dates you will love this chutney. It's sweet yet savory, and perfect for the autumn and winter table.

View Recipe

Apricot Raisin Chutney

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (12)

If fresh apricots are available in your local market, make a pot of this golden sauce. Can it or keep it in the refrigerator until you're ready to serve it for Thanksgiving, or enjoy it with meats and cheeses.

View Recipe

Cranberry Pomegranate Relish

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (13)

This variation on a cranberry sauce is decidedly different. It's deeply flavored with pomegranate molasses and brown sugar. Stirring in fresh pomegranate arils at the last minute, adds crunch and fresh tartness.

View Recipe

Red Currant Jam

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (14)

Red currant jam or jelly was traditionally served with game and makes a spectacular partner for turkey. Red currants are naturally quite sour but are sweetened just right in this recipe from Christine Ferber, a legendary jam and jelly maker.

View Recipe

Cranberry Ginger Jelly

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (15)

It's a jelly not a sauce! And, it's an elegant variation on the typical cranberry sauce with the cranberry flavor tempered by fresh ginger. Another bonus, it's very simple to make.

View Recipe

Read the original article on Martha Stewart.

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce (2024)

FAQs

14 Homemade Condiments to Serve With Turkey—That Aren't Cranberry Sauce? ›

Get these recipes for homemade fruit sauce, pomegranate fig mostarda, homemade applesauce, bacon jam and chimichurri.

What can be used instead of cranberry sauce? ›

Get these recipes for homemade fruit sauce, pomegranate fig mostarda, homemade applesauce, bacon jam and chimichurri.

What sauce compliments turkey? ›

There's nothing quite like the combination of turkey with sweet-tart cranberry sauce.

What can I put on turkey besides gravy? ›

There's homemade cranberry ketchup, or cherry ketchup, tangy and sweet. Or you could top your turkey with a different kind of staple sauce altogether: simple, classic pesto. The Dining staff is taking questions on Thanksgiving cooking, drinking, entertaining, or any other holiday hurdles.

What kind of fruit sauce is traditionally served with turkey? ›

Turkey. So the Christmas tradition of turkey with cranberry sauce has been borrowed from the North American thanksgiving combination of turkeys and cranberries.

What is the best substitute for cranberries? ›

There's not a direct substitute for fresh cranberries, but you could make a relish or chutney using a combination of fresh cherries and pomegranates, as well as a small amount of dried cranberries or dried figs. The flavor will be more sweet than tart, but it serves the same purpose.

Why do we have cranberry sauce with turkey? ›

Turkey is often dry, salty, and bland, which makes it the perfect partner for something sweet and moist. Cranberries are not overly sweet. Their tartness pairs well with the more bland-tasting turkey. Our palates would be bored by singular tastes.

What is the best condiment for turkey? ›

Mayonnaise is favored by the majority, however. (Both Hellmann's and Duke's have adamant fan bases.) Mayo is a simple and apt pairing when the sandwich consists of richly flavored dark meat.

What tastes good with turkey? ›

Simple turkey sides
  • 1) Bay roasted smashed potatoes. ...
  • 2) Green bean and goats cheese salad. ...
  • 3) Brussels sprouts and speck gratin. ...
  • 4) Couscous salad. ...
  • 5) Rocket coleslaw. ...
  • 6) Sweet potato and chive damper. ...
  • 7) Honey macadamia stuffing. ...
  • 8) Pork stuffing.

What pairs best with turkey? ›

Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, and Riesling are excellent choices to accompany your turkey dinner. Sauvignon Blanc is a light and citrusy wine that compliments turkey well, as it doesn't overpower the dish's flavor. Chardonnay is a more robust white wine featuring notes of vanilla and butter.

How to jazz up canned turkey gravy? ›

Just as you might add condiments like soy sauce, miso paste, Worcestershire sauce, or even a splash of sherry or cider vinegar to your favorite gravy recipe, incorporate them into store-bought gravy for a more complex flavor. Start by adding just a little at a time, and continue until you reach a flavor you enjoy.

What can I add to turkey gravy to make it taste better? ›

There's almost nothing a few snips of fresh herbs won't make better. When you're heating up the gravy, add in a variety of your favorite herbs—think Thanksgiving classics like rosemary, thyme, parsley, or sage—and let the gravy extract some of the flavor while it heats. Strain the herbs from the gravy before serving.

What can I use instead of cranberry sauce? ›

Consider a chutney with fresh and dried fruit, a tangy citrus marmalade, and even bacon-onion "jam." The recipes we've gathered are sweet and tart or savory and aromatic, they include the spices, nuts, and deep flavors we associate with autumn and winter, so you won't miss the cranberries one bit.

What is the most famous sauce in turkey? ›

Important Turkish Sauces and Dips
  • Haydari. Haydari is a Tukish yogurt sauce that is often eaten with savory dishes like meatballs or kebabs. ...
  • Ezme. Ezme is a tomato-based sauce that is similar to salsa. ...
  • Morney Sosu. ...
  • Humus. ...
  • Muhammara.

What fruit is popular in turkey? ›

Quince, strawberries, and citrus fruits are produced and sold everywhere during the entire winter. Quince is rather tart and aromatic and is extremely tasty! In fact, Türkiye exports quince to many countries across the world.

What is the closest flavor to cranberries? ›

Currants: Both red and black currants can substitute for cranberries due to their tart flavor profile, especially in jams and syrups.

What is the purpose of cranberry sauce? ›

Cranberry sauce or cranberry jam is a sauce or relish made out of cranberries, commonly served as a condiment or a side dish with Thanksgiving dinner in North America and Christmas dinner in the United Kingdom and Canada.

Is cranberry sauce similar to jam? ›

Calling this dish a “sauce” is a bit of a misnomer, as cranberry sauce is actually a simple fruit jam. Cranberries are naturally high in pectin (a naturally occuring gel). When cranberries are cooked with sugar and acid (such as orange or lemon juice), the pectin is released and gels the fruit.

Is jellied cranberry the same as cranberry sauce? ›

It is the whole-berry version that is “cranberry sauce.” The jellied cylinder qualifies as sauce only by relation, like a legacy applicant at Yale. Yet it is beloved — not as a sauce, exactly, but as a food group of its own.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arline Emard IV

Last Updated:

Views: 5428

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arline Emard IV

Birthday: 1996-07-10

Address: 8912 Hintz Shore, West Louie, AZ 69363-0747

Phone: +13454700762376

Job: Administration Technician

Hobby: Paintball, Horseback riding, Cycling, Running, Macrame, Playing musical instruments, Soapmaking

Introduction: My name is Arline Emard IV, I am a cheerful, gorgeous, colorful, joyous, excited, super, inquisitive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.