How To Make the Best Homemade Snickerdoodles (2024)

Posted onDecember 4, 2020February 7, 2024Updated onFebruary 7, 2024Cookies, Desserts

There are few things more comforting than freshly baked snickerdoodles dusted in cinnamon sugar. This version uses baking powder, which eliminates the need for cream of tarter plus baking soda)!

What’s So Great About Snickerdoodles?

These are my youngest daughter’sfavorite cookie. And with good reason!

These homemade snickerdoodles are soft, yet firm, with a flavorful bite ofvanilla sugar cookieand cinnamon sugar. Nothing beats enjoying one warm and fresh out of the oven!

They’re the perfectcold weather cookieand are made even better after dipping into a cold glass of milk or a warm mug of hot chocolate.

I love howsimple and deliciousthese snickerdoodles are. You won’t find any dry oats, chocolate chips, or candy pieces in these beauts. Just a simple vanilla sugar cookie and a coating of sweet cinnamon sugar.

And the best part is that I’ll share my method forpreventing your cookies from spreadingand flattening out in the oven.

Key Ingredients for Homemade Snickerdoodles

For thesugar cookie dough:

• Room temperature butter:Softened butter ensures a creamy, smooth butter-sugar mixture, which is key for achieving the texture we want for this dough.
• Sugar: White granulated sugar is best for sugar cookies because it is purely sweet instead of carmel-y sweet like light or dark brown sugar, and it won’t change the color of the light yellow dough.
• Extra-large egg at room temperature:Like with the butter, it’s crucial to make sure your egg is at room temperature so it doesn’t re-chill the softened butter.
• Vanilla: If you’re going to be particular about any ingredient, it should be vanilla. Opt for pure vanilla extract over imitation.
• Flour: I used bread flour and was happy with the result, but you could also use all-purpose.
• Salt: This helps balance out the sweetness of the sugar and cinnamon sugar dusting.
• Baking powder: Along with the egg, this serves as a leavening agent for the sugar cookie dough and it replaces the older versions, which have cream of tarter and baking soda.

And for thecinnamon sugar dust, simply combine 1/2 cup of granulated sugar with 1 tablespoon of cinnamon, or more to taste.

Overview of How to Make the Cookies

Tips for Preventing Flat Snickerdoodle Cookies

I’ve read that some people experienceproblems with spreadingwhile making snickerdoodles andsugar cookiesin general. I didn’t experience this problem, although I should mention that I didn’t bake the dough the same night that I made it. I believe baking with chilled dough was key in preventing the cookies from spreading.

I should mention that I took the snickerdoodle dough out of the refrigerator while the oven preheated. So, even though the chilled dough warmed up a bit before baking, the cookies still stood up well.

So, why do snickerdoodles spread out while baking, and how can we stop this from happening? Check out these tips to find out:

1. You might be over-mixing your sugar and butter mixture.Make sure to scrape down the sides of the bowl after creaming these ingredients to ensure that they are sufficiently mixed, but don’t mix them too much. A minute or two should suffice.
2. The issue may be your flour.Using a low-protein bread flour (10-12%) can also prevent spreading. I used King Arthur bread flour, and it worked out very well.
3. You might be baking them at too low of a temperature.If you are using a home oven that is non-convection, try baking at 375 degrees instead of 350 degrees. Too low of a temperature can also dry out your cookies.
4. Try chilling your dough until it’s firm, then slicing it before baking.I formed the dough into balls. Because I wanted a evenly baked cookie (not puffed up in the middle, I gently flattened by dough balls before baking). Just make sure the dough has been chilled before trying this method. I also like to make sure the dough balls are uniform in size (I use a cookie scoop). You can also form the dough into a log and sliced them at a thickness of about 3/8″, which is halfway between 1/4 inch and 1/2 inch.

How Do I Know When My Snickerdoodles Are Done Cooking?

Everyone lovessoft snickerdoodles, but it can be difficultto knowwhen they’re cooked perfectly and not overcooked.

If they get too brown, chances are that they will be overdone, resulting ina dry, crumbly cookie. Cookies tend to set up a bit more after they are taken out of the oven, so make sure to allot your cookies time to continue cooking on the baking sheet until they’re firm enough to transfer to a wire rack to fully cool.

To test if your snickerdoodle cookies are done, try lifting the edge of a cookie slightly. If it lifts off the cookie sheet, chances are they’re done!

How To Store and Freeze Leftover Cookies

The chances of you having leftover snickerdoodles are pretty low, but if you do, here’s how to store and freeze them:

• To store leftover baked snickerdoodles, keep in an airtight container or Ziplock bag at room temperature for up to five days.
• To freeze baked cookies, store in a freezer-safe container or Ziplock bag for up to six months.
• To freeze raw dough, roll into a log using wax paper and store in a freezer-safe container or Ziplock bag for up to three months. You can also roll the chilled, raw dough into balls, roll them in cinnamon sugar, and freeze the same way.

Tip:Make some extra cinnamon sugar and keep in your pantry to use when making these cookies at a later time.

More Cookie Recipes To Try

If you liked these homemade snickerdoodles, then you’ll love these othercookierecipes:

• Ricotta Cookies
• Italian Wedding Cookies
• Pignoli Cookies
• Lilla’s Famous Peach Cookies
• Big, Soft Sugar Cookies

📖 Recipe