Is Natural Deodorant Better? Pros and Cons (2024)

Observing proper hygiene will definitely make you feel GOOD and CONFIDENT. Doing so will help you prevent irritations, control bacteria, manage sweat and body odor, and maintain skin health.

One of the ways to keep these in check is by using a deodorant.

For consumers who want to avoid the effects of harsh chemicals, the best way to go would be natural deodorants.

But is a natural deodorant better than conventional deodorant formulas?

We will discover the answer to this question as we uncover the advantages and disadvantages of natural deodorants. This article will also address allergies and sensitivities, plus a checklist on what to look for in a natural deodorant.

Are you ready to end the debate on who's who between natural deodorants and antiperspirants? Let's get started!

What are the Advantages of Natural Deodorants?

Is Natural Deodorant Better? Pros and Cons (1)

Shop Now

What is the first thing that comes to mind when asked what a natural deodorant does?

For sure, it is somewhere between reducing exposure to harsh ingredients and reaping the benefits of aluminum-free and natural formulation, plus a whole lot more.

Unravel the prominent pros that will make you consider natural deodorant products as your personal choice!

Reduced exposure to harmful ingredients

One of the reasons why people prefer natural formulas is reduced exposure to bad ingredients. Natural deodorant works wonders even without harsh chemicals, including:

  • parabens;
  • phthalates;
  • artificial fragrances; and
  • other synthetic materials.

Without these ingredients, you can combat odor and prevent sweating without worrying about severe skin problems and irritations, making it suitable for sensitive skin. It also reduces the risk of contracting serious illnesses even with long-term use.

Aluminum-free and natural ingredients

Most natural products for deodorants are aluminum-free and made of bio-based ingredients.

But why is it essential to have an aluminum-free deodorant?

Apart from being tagged as a skin irritant, there are claims and studies linking aluminum-based deodorants to breast cancer and Alzheimer's disease, making it a concern for most people.

While organizations like the National Cancer Institute have not found a solid link between such diseases and deodorant use, consumers are still reluctant to aluminum compound exposure.

On the other hand, cosmetic products, including deodorants, that are made of bio-based and eco-friendly ingredients are MORE APPEALING to the public. Aside from not containing harsh chemicals, they also favor eco-warriors and vegans who prefer using natural options.

Transparency

Natural deodorant brands put a premium on the transparency of their ingredient list, helping consumers make informed buying decisions.

It keeps consumers at ease, knowing that what they use differs from conventional deodorants or aluminum-based antiperspirants that may contain harsh chemicals. It also frees them from worries of getting illnesses like breast cancer.

What are the Disadvantages of Natural Deodorants?

Speaking of informed buying decisions, you must also know that natural deodorants have its fair share of cons:

  • It is generally more expensive than other options.
  • It is less effective in reducing sweat, which is a downside for those who perspire heavily. You may need to reapply natural deodorant frequently throughout the day.
  • You may still experience sweating even when applying deodorant, especially if you are used to antiperspirants. This is a normal mechanism as the body adjusts to its components.

Deodorants vs Antiperspirants

The sweat released from the area with the most hair follicles (apocrine glands) is odorless. It only becomes stinky when it gets contaminated with bacteria.

Hence, people use deodorants and antiperspirants to eliminate body odor. While these two products are utilized for similar reasons, they work quite differently.

Here are a few points to distinguish one from the other:

Antiperspirants

  • Antiperspirant products contain aluminum-based components (e.g., chloride, zirconium, and chlorohydrate)
  • Antiperspirants block sweat glands, which in turn reduce sweat or absorb sweat

Deodorants

  • Contains little to no aluminum compounds
  • Can control odor through antimicrobial ingredients and fragrances.
  • Natural counterparts utilize plant-based ingredients, such as tea tree oil and tapioca starch, that care for the skin.

Allergies and Sensitivities

Is Natural Deodorant Better? Pros and Cons (2)

Despite having several benefits, some people still experience adverse reactions to natural deodorants, like with conventional body care and skin care products. This could be due to allergies and sensitivities to certain ingredients.

The most common skin irritation is contact dermatitis. This happens when allergens come into contact with the skin. It is often characterized by redness, itchiness, and skin swelling.

Dermatitis is typically triggered by fragrances, especially those derived from essential oils. It can also be caused by deodorants containing coconut oil, baking soda, and shea butter.

Nevertheless, there is nothing a board-certified dermatologist cannot solve when it comes to your skin. Hence, it is important to consult with one when you encounter issues after using a natural deodorant.

What to Look for in a Natural Deodorant?

Understandably, you want to switch to natural deodorant formulas from conventional deodorants and antiperspirants to avoid harmful chemical compounds.

However, doing a one to two-week detox is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. This will help you transition from aluminum-based antiperspirants to natural deodorants smoothly, helping you achieve that perfect body chemistry.

While resting your skin, start looking for your next holy grail. A few things to remember mind when doing so are the following:

  • Transparent ingredients list - This helps in noting down its components and ensures that the formula uses sustainable ingredients. It will also help you check what essential oils and fragrances are incorporated, as these are possible skin irritants.
  • Active ingredient - Assess if it can adequately control odor by identifying the active ingredient (e.g., baking soda)
  • Customer reviews - Customer reviews will make your decision-making process much easier as you learn from first-hand experiences.

Key Takeaways on Whether Natural Deodorant is Better

So, is natural deodorant better than conventional antiperspirants and beauty products? Not necessarily, but some consumers prefer it to be on the safe side.

Despite the scientific evidence talking about long-term exposure to harsh ingredients like aluminum salts and other aluminum-based compounds that would lead to serious health conditions (e.g., breast cancer.), there is no solid link between that and the use of aluminum-based deodorants.

Still, going for natural deodorants is a perfectly safe choice, especially for those with allergies and sensitivities and consumers who want to AVOID harsh chemicals.

Natural deodorants for kids and adults also have a transparent ingredient list. This makes it easier to identify its formulation and determine if it can neutralize odor without triggering allergies.

Many deodorants in the market containing artificial ingredients can neutralize odor, but it can be a tricky choice for those who instantly react to any contact with allergens. In this case, it is best to explore your compatibility with natural deodorant products!

Is Natural Deodorant Better? Pros and Cons (2024)

FAQs

Is natural deodorant actually better for you? ›

Research says no. But speculation over this claim has caused some shoppers to consider natural deodorant options. Natural deodorants often use witch hazel, baking soda and essential oils to eliminate odors.

Do natural deodorants even work? ›

Natural deodorant reduces the scent of the sweat, but does not reduce the amount of sweat the body produces,” Collins told Verywell. “So if your main concern is the appearance of sweat in the armpit area of your shirt, deodorant will be completely ineffective in reducing the dreaded armpit sweat marks.”

What are the cons of wearing deodorant? ›

Most concerns about deodorants and antiperspirants are based on a theory that pores in the skin under the arms can become clogged with aluminum or parabens, which can increase the level of estrogen in the body, either from the compounds themselves or from hormones in the skin that can't escape through sweat.

What happens to your body when you use natural deodorant? ›

Here's what you might experience during your journey: More Sweat – At the start, you may notice more sweat than usual. This happens because, unlike antiperspirants, natural deodorants don't block your sweat glands. While it might feel uncomfortable at first, it's actually a good sign.

Is it worth switching to natural deodorant? ›

According to the U.S. Food & Drug Administration, conventional antiperspirant deodorants are safe — so there's no need to worry or switch to a natural deodorant on account of your overall health. However, personal preference or ingredient sensitivity may lead you to consider switching to a natural deodorant.

What is the healthiest deodorant to use? ›

Below, we list top-rated and Select staff-favorite natural deodorants that are in line with our experts' guidance.
  • Native ​​Regular Deodorant.
  • Necessaire The Deodorant Gel.
  • Schmidt's Deodorant Stick.
  • Salt & Stone Natural Deodorant.
  • Soapwalla Deodorant Cream.
  • Evolvetogether Natural Deodorant.
  • Kosas Chemistry Deodorant.
May 10, 2023

Why do I smell after switching to natural deodorant? ›

"When switching from an antiperspirant to a deodorant, you are removing the aluminum and releasing waste which has been blocked. This is a natural process as part of our body's built-in mechanisms, but it may contribute to releasing some slightly unusual body odor in comparison to what you are used to.

Do you sweat less with natural deodorant? ›

Unlike natural deodorants—which don't block sweating, but instead mask or prevent odor—antiperspirants are considered over-the-counter drugs that are subject to FDA regulation. FACT: "NATURAL" IS AN EMPTY TERM. The FDA has never established a regulatory definition for “natural” in cosmetics products like deodorant.

Why did I stop using natural deodorant? ›

Skin Irritation: Ingredients in natural deodorants, particularly high levels of baking soda, can sometimes lead to skin irritation or discomfort, especially for those with sensitive skin or allergies to specific natural components.

Do Europeans wear deodorant? ›

The majority of Europeans regard the use of a deodorant or antiperspirant as a necessary part of their personal hygiene routine, leaving manufacturers little room to drive volume growth in this mature market.

Is it OK if I don't use deodorant? ›

“If you stop wearing deodorant or antiperspirant, you can develop a stronger odor over time,” Doyle said. “When you stop using (such products) and sweat more, this creates a breeding ground for bacterial and fungal overgrowth, which can cause odor to become stronger.”

Why can't i use natural deodorant? ›

Some people may be sensitive to certain ingredients, such as baking soda or essential oils so you may need to experiment to find the right one for you. If you find that a natural deodorant is causing skin irritation or discomfort, it's important to switch to a different product or to consult with a dermatologist.

Can I just start using natural deodorant? ›

The problem is that, depending on your skin's unique microbiome, it can take a little while for your body to adjust to the switch-up, and that (sweaty, smelly) transition can last anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. Yes, potentially weeks. The transition time scared me off for so long.

Is aluminum-free deodorant better? ›

While there is no “direct link” between aluminum and cancer, according to the American Cancer Society, using an aluminum-free deodorant is better as you're not putting unnecessary chemicals in your body. Aluminum-free deodorants usually contain natural ingredients that are gentler on the skin.

Why is it better to use aluminum free deodorant? ›

While there is no “direct link” between aluminum and cancer, according to the American Cancer Society, using an aluminum-free deodorant is better as you're not putting unnecessary chemicals in your body. Aluminum-free deodorants usually contain natural ingredients that are gentler on the skin.

Is there a natural deodorant that actually works? ›

For Staying Dry: Glossier Deodorant

Why We Love It: The first deodorant from beauty powerhouse, Glossier, is refillable and aluminum-free. Available in four scents, the formula uses a blend of naturally sourced ingredients to keep you dry and odor-free.

Do armpits adjust to natural deodorant? ›

The Adjustment Period When Switching to Natural Deodorant

If you are just switching to natural deodorant, your body may need 1-3 weeks to adjust. But if you've been using antiperspirants your whole life, it could take a bit longer as the sweat glands in your underarms are going to go through quite the adjustment.

What happens when you stop using aluminum deodorant? ›

Your body odor is probably going to smell different, and potentially stronger, than what you're used to. That's because your body is simultaneously purging its sweat glands and recalibrating the balance of microscopic organisms that live on your skin. It's establishing a new normal.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 5976

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.