Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (2024)

In the world of deodorants we have a lot of choices, but how do you decide which will work best for you? Does it come down to brand loyalty or do you use whatever is on promotion? Do you go for a roll-on or stick? Will one type keep you smelling better than the other? Stick and roll-on antiperspirants are the two main products on the market. They are both very good at controlling sweat and odor, but do they work in the same manner?

By the end of this comparison guide, you will know the ins and outs of choosing the best type of deodorant for you. We'll go over the basics of both roll-ons and stick deodorant so that you can make an informed decision next time you're out shopping. Stay with us, and you'll have all the knowledge you need to be an underarm deodorant master!

Did you know?

The first deodorant was a cream applied by hands to underarms in 1888.

Before getting into the differences first let’s understand what is a roll-on deodorant and what is a stick deodorant.

What is a Roll-on Deodorant?

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (1)

Underarm roll on deodorants are the most common type of deodorant to use nowadays. A roll-on deodorant is a type of deodorant that is applied to the skin using a rolling motion. The deodorant is typically in the form of a gel or liquid, and is applied to the skin using a rollerball applicator. Thus, they may leave the skin feeling wet. But it gets dry after a few seconds. Roll-on deodorants are a convenient and mess-free way to apply deodorant.

What is a Stick Deodorant?

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (2)

A stick deodorant is a type of deodorant that comes in the form of a solid stick. It is applied directly to the skin, typically under the arms, to provide long-lasting odor protection. Stick deodorants are usually made with a combination of sweat-absorbing ingredients, like aluminum chloride, and fragrance. Choose a deodorant formula that glides smoothly and doesn't leave white marks on clothes.

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (3)

Roll on deodorants was invented in America in the 1950's.

Roll-on Vs. Stick Deodorant

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (4)

There are two main ways to apply deodorant, roll-on or stick. It is all a matter of preference. But what is the difference between the two? The stick deodorant has a more solid consistency than the roll-on does. The roll-on version is more like a liquid.

The stick is more effective for those who have a problem with excessive sweating in the underarms. Roll-on deodorant is more effective for those who are on their feet a lot and who want to avoid the mess of the stick. It is also good for those who are traveling and want to ensure that they can pack light.


Roll-on Deodorant

Stick Deodorant

With its unique ball applicator, it helps contour your underarms

Stick deodorant sticks usually come in oval containers

Has a liquid or gel form

Has a firmer, drier application

Travel-friendly

Travel-friendly

Controllable coverage

Controllable coverage

Effective at controlling sweating

Effective at masking odor

Stain-free

Can leave stain marks on your clothes

Roll-on Deodorant: The mess-free formula

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (5)

Roll-on deodorants are more effective at killing the bacteria that cause sweat and odor.

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (6)

Roll-on deodorants are also more effective at covering up body odor than stick deodorants. This is because roll-on deodorants can form a thicker layer on the skin, which helps to trap body odor.

Roll-on deodorants are more convenient to use

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (7)

Roll-on deodorants are a lot easier to use than their stick cousins. You simply roll them over your armpits and you're done. No more fiddling around with a stick, or worrying about them dripping down your leg and ruining your trousers. They are more convenient to use, especially when you are on the go.

Roll-on deodorants are stain free

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (8)

Roll-on deodorants are the perfect solution for anyone who wants to avoid the mess and hassle of traditional deodorants. They go on smoothly and evenly, without leaving any telltale white streaks or stains on your clothes. And best of all, they're virtually impossible to accidentally apply too much, so you'll never have to worry about looking like you've overdone it.

Roll-on deodorants take slightly longer to dry

Roll-on deodorants take slightly longer to dry, but they are worth the wait! This is because the roll-on deodorant is applied directly to the skin, which can take a few minutes to absorb the product.

Stick Deodorant: A controllable formula

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (9)

Deodorant sticks may leave a stain on your clothes

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (10)

Deodorant sticks are a great way to keep your underarms dry and free of odor, but they can also leave a nasty stain on your clothes. If you're not careful, your deodorant stick can leave a white, powdery residue on your clothing that is difficult to remove. To avoid this, be sure to apply your deodorant stick to clean, dry skin.

Stick deodorants don't leave a wet sensation

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (11)

Stick deodorants are becoming increasingly popular, as they don't leave a wet sensation on the skin. This is because they are formulated with a dry resin, which helps to absorb sweat and keep the skin dry. Stick deodorants are also long-lasting and provide good protection against body odor.

Stick deodorants may cause a burning sensation

Stick deodorants may cause a burning sensation because of their high concentration of alcohol. When applied to the skin, the alcohol quickly evaporates and leaves behind a burning sensation. This is especially true if the deodorant is applied to sensitive areas such as the underarms. If you experience a burning sensation after applying a stick deodorant, it is best to rinse the area with cool water and avoid using the product again.

Stick deodorant has controllable coverage

Stick deodorants have controllable coverage, so you can choose how much or how little you want to apply. This makes them great for those who want to control their perspiration without using a lot of products and they are easy to re-apply.

The Power of Chemist at Play Rollon Deodorant

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (12)

The Chemist at Play’s underarm roll on is infused with 4%lactic acid and 1% mandelic acid to decrease the melanin production and increase cell turnover, thereby, reducing hyperpigmentation.These AHA’S blend brighten and exfoliates the skin giving you smoother and odor-free underarm.

Key Features:

  • Long-lasting freshness and odor control
  • Does not drys out skin
  • Leaves no white residue on clothes
  • The product is derma-tested
  • Increase the collagen production

Who wins?

So here we are, with the winner!

When looking for the right deodorant, it's important to find one that works for you. In this blog, we compared two of the most popular deodorant methods – the stick and the roll-on. From our research, we found that roll-on deodorant is the winner! It comes in a variety of formulas and scents and is easily applied to the underarm area. Roll-on deodorant does not only work by drying out sweat and bacteria but also lasts longer.

FAQS About Roll-on vs Stick Deodorant

Can I use roll-on every day?

Yes, you can use roll-on every day. It is a great way to keep your skin hydrated and looking its best. “A roll-on is a great addition to anyone's everyday grooming habits because it can help with keeping the skin under your arms healthy.

Are roll-on deodorants hygienic?

Yes, roll-on deodorants are more hygienic to use because you are not exposed to as many germs when using a roll-on. Also, you can more easily control how much deodorant you are applying to your skin, which helps to reduce the amount of bacteria that is being transferred.

Does roll-on stop you from sweating?

Roll-on deodorants combat the bacteria to do away with underarm odor. To reduce sweat production and prevent body odor, the roll-on forms temporary gel-like plugs at the top of sweat pores.

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (13)

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? (2024)

FAQs

Underarm Stick vs Roll On? Who Wins? ›

Roll-on deodorants are more effective at killing the bacteria that cause sweat and odor. Roll-on deodorants are also more effective at covering up body odor than stick deodorants. This is because roll-on deodorants can form a thicker layer on the skin, which helps to trap body odor.

Is it better to use a stick or roll on deodorant? ›

With that being said, if you're in a hurry, or prefer the feeling of a dry application, a stick deodorant may be your best bet. If you prefer a soft application with a powdery finish and have some time to enjoy the little pleasures in life, choose a roll-on deodorant.

Which works best roll on stick or spray deodorant? ›

Spray is less effective

As far as mildness goes it doesn't matter if you use a roll on deodorant or a spray on deodorant. However, I would recommend you use a good roll on or tube rather than a spray. One reason is effectiveness. Research has found that only 11.4% of a spray reaches the skin.

What are the benefits of underarm roll on? ›

Underarm roll-on is designed to help reduce the amount of sweat that your body produces, and it can be a great way to stay dry and comfortable throughout the day. It can also help to prevent body odor by keeping the sweat from mixing with bacteria on the skin.

Is gel or stick deodorant better? ›

Okay, then – is solid deodorant better than gel? The formulation for solid deodorants may not be as potent as some of their gel counterparts, but they still do the job. Solid deodorants adequately prevent body odor. If you don't mind the slightly sticky feeling, a solid deodorant will work just fine for you.

What is the disadvantage of stick deodorant? ›

CONS OF STICK DEODORANT:

Staining – may leave marks on clothes. Plastic and non-recyclable packaging (even if it's a “refill”). Runs out quickly. Unhygienic – using the same applicator allows bacteria to accumulate.

What is the most efficient way to use deodorant? ›

Roll on 2-3 swipes of deodorant or antiperspirant under each arm, covering the entire underarm zone. Wait until your deodorant is dry before putting on your shirt – and then you're good to go!

Why is stick deodorant better than spray? ›

The benefits of a deodorant stick

Whether you're traveling or simply going for a workout, you can stay smelling fresh and clean wherever you are. Stick deodorants can also be applied with more precision than dry sprays, allowing you to cover only the areas you want, and making them a perfect pick for on-the-go care.

What is the most effective form of deodorant? ›

For most, an antiperspirant is ideal. A deodorant masks odors, while an antiperspirant blocks sweat glands, reducing wetness and body odors. For maximum wetness protection, you'll want to look for an aluminum-based antiperspirant, and the dermatologists we spoke to tend to favor stick and roll-on varieties.

Why does roll on work better than spray? ›

Roll-ons deliver more active ingredient directly to the area in question. This makes them ideal for guys who want to reduce sweating more than simply deodorise. It's yours. Unlike sprays, which can be used by more than one person, nobody ever asks to borrow a roll-on!

What is the best thing for armpits? ›

Treatment options
  1. Use topical antiperspirants. Tired of the sweat stains on your shirt? ...
  2. Wait between showering and dressing. ...
  3. Shave your armpits. ...
  4. Avoid sweat-inducing foods. ...
  5. Eat more foods that reduce sweat. ...
  6. Stay hydrated. ...
  7. Wear breathable, loose-fitting clothing. ...
  8. Skip the caffeine.

What to avoid in roll on deodorant? ›

By avoiding these ingredients and choosing a natural deodorant alternative, you can ensure that you stay fresh and healthy without compromising on your well-being.
  • Aluminum Chlorohydrate, Aluminum Zirconium, and Aluminum Chloride. ...
  • Parabens. ...
  • Phthalates. ...
  • Triclosan. ...
  • Baking Soda. ...
  • Talc. ...
  • Alcohol. ...
  • Propylene Glycol.
Oct 12, 2023

Which roll on is best for smelly underarms? ›

Perspirex Roll-On Strong 20ml is a classic antiperspirant - trusted for years, that controls sweat and odour.

Is roll-on better than stick? ›

The stick is more effective for those who have a problem with excessive sweating in the underarms. Roll-on deodorant is more effective for those who are on their feet a lot and who want to avoid the mess of the stick. It is also good for those who are traveling and want to ensure that they can pack light.

What is the healthiest deodorant to use? ›

Below, we list top-rated and Select staff-favorite natural deodorants that are in line with our experts' guidance.
  • Native ​​Regular Deodorant.
  • Necessaire The Deodorant Gel.
  • Schmidt's Deodorant Stick.
  • Salt & Stone Natural Deodorant.
  • Soapwalla Deodorant Cream.
  • Evolvetogether Natural Deodorant.
  • Kosas Chemistry Deodorant.
May 10, 2023

How often should you go through a stick of deodorant? ›

This will vary from person to person, but generally we say about 3 months. Given that we don't use filler ingredients, and you only need 1 – 2 swipes per application, you may find it lasts you even longer.

What is the best form of deodorant? ›

Roll-On Deodorant

Although roll-on application is slightly slower than a spray, this type of product tends to last longer than aerosol formulas. Since roll-on formulas have more of a water base, it doesn't leave those nasty white marks!

Is powder deodorant better than stick? ›

Powder deodorants are ideal for people with sensitive skin. They are generally less irritating than conventional stick or spray deodorants, and the puff application allows for a gentler, more even application. When we sweat, the moisture on our skin can create an environment that is conducive to the growth of bacteria.

Is roll on deodorant better for your skin? ›

This is down to personal choice but, if you have sensitive skin, it is best to opt for a roll-on product. This is because aerosols can contain chemicals that have the potential to cause skin irritation, allergic reactions and even breathing difficulties.

Is solid deodorant better than roll on? ›

This choice comes down to personal preference, and some key differences can help you decide. Skin sensitivity sometimes plays a role as well in which deodorant is best for you. For example, oval containers might dig into your skin during application. If this is the case for you, roll-ons may be better.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated:

Views: 6112

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.